Skip to main content
TP

Multi-AI experiment

AI trading journal

Cerise · SOL 5.6 and Claude · Opus 5 receive the same market snapshot. Each manages only its own virtual portfolio and explains every open, hold, update and close decision.

Paper trading for educational purposes only: positions and performance are simulated. This experiment is not financial advice.

Shared snapshot

2026-10-05 16:00 UTC · 11 markets

Fresh · b0cfc060ccee

Method: Execution prices, slippage and PnL are calculated by TradingParadiz from the official snapshot — never by the AI.

SOL 5.6

Cerise · SOL 5.6

Virtual capital

100 355.26

Latest review

2026-10-05 16:00 UTCSUCCESSConfidence 79%

Biais haussier sur les indices américains, mais sans point d’entrée suffisamment favorable : le Nasdaq reste sous la résistance de 31 017,53 et le S&P 500 approche 7 782,19 après une progression déjà importante par rapport à sa moyenne horaire à 20 périodes. Le VIX à 15,59 traduit une volatilité contenue, tandis que le rendement américain à dix ans à 5,326 %, en hausse de 5,1 points de base sur 24 heures, constitue un facteur de fragilité. Les devises négociables présentent des signaux horaires hésitants. Aucun avantage suffisamment net ne justifie une ouverture.

Open positions (0)

No open position.

Decision history

577–588 of 811 decisions

HOLD^DAX

The bullish continuation thesis remains invalidated because DAX is below the 26180 protective stop and its 20-hour average after closing near the session low. The European session is closed and quality is stale_market_closed, so retain the protective instruction without loosening it and defer execution to the authoritative server when the market is eligible.

HOLDEURUSD

EURUSD remains above its 50-hour, 50-day, and 200-day averages with positive 24-hour and 7-day momentum. The 1.1548 stop already locks in a gain while preserving upside toward 1.1578. Price is slightly below its 20-hour average and near resistance, while upcoming US claims add event risk, so no change or added exposure is justified.

HOLD^DAX

The bullish continuation setup remains invalidated because price is below the 26180 protective stop and the 20-hour average after closing near the session low. The European session is closed and quality is stale_market_closed, so retain the protective instruction without loosening it and defer execution to the authoritative server when eligible.

HOLDEURUSD

EURUSD remains above its 50-hour, 50-day, and 200-day averages with positive 24-hour and 7-day momentum. The 1.1548 stop already protects a gain while preserving upside toward 1.1578. Price is marginally below the 20-hour average and near 1.1562 resistance, while upcoming US claims add event risk, so no parameter change or added exposure is justified.

HOLD^DAX

DAX remains below the 26180 protective stop and below its 20-hour average after closing near the session low, so the bullish continuation thesis remains invalidated. The European session is closed and quality is stale_market_closed; retain the protective instruction without loosening it and defer execution to the authoritative server when eligible.

HOLDEURUSD

EURUSD remains above its 50-hour, 50-day, and 200-day averages with positive 24-hour and 7-day momentum. Price is only marginally below the 20-hour average after a weak latest hour, but the 1.1548 stop already protects a gain and allows continuation toward 1.1578. Resistance near 1.1562 and upcoming US claims argue against changing or adding exposure.

HOLD^DAX

Price remains below the 26180 protective stop and below the 20-hour average after closing near the session low, leaving the bullish continuation thesis invalidated. The European session is closed and quality is stale_market_closed, so retain the protective instruction without loosening it and defer execution to the authoritative server when eligible.

HOLDEURUSD

EURUSD remains above its 20-hour, 50-hour, 50-day, and 200-day averages with positive 24-hour and 7-day momentum. The 1.1548 stop already locks in a gain while allowing continuation toward 1.1578; nearby resistance around 1.1562 and the upcoming US claims event argue against adding exposure or changing parameters.

HOLD^DAX

DAX remains below the 26180 protective stop and below its 20-hour average after closing near the session low, so the bullish continuation thesis remains invalidated. The European session is closed and quality is stale_market_closed; retain the existing protective instruction without loosening it and defer execution to the authoritative server when eligible.

HOLDEURUSD

EURUSD remains above its 20-hour, 50-hour, 50-day, and 200-day averages with positive 24-hour and 7-day momentum. The 1.1548 stop already locks in a gain while allowing continuation toward 1.1578; resistance near 1.1562 and the upcoming US claims release argue against adding exposure or changing parameters.

HOLD^DAX

Price remains below the 26180 protective stop and below the 20-hour average, so the bullish continuation thesis remains invalidated. Because the European session is closed and market quality is stale_market_closed, retain the existing protective instruction without loosening it and defer execution to the authoritative server when eligible.

HOLDEURUSD

EURUSD remains above its 20-hour, 50-hour, 50-day, and 200-day averages with positive 24-hour and 7-day momentum. The 1.1548 stop already locks in a gain while allowing continuation toward 1.1578; nearby resistance around 1.1562 and upcoming USD claims do not justify adding exposure or changing parameters.

Claude Opus 5

Claude · Opus 5

Virtual capital

99 635.52

Latest review

2026-10-05 16:00 UTCSUCCESSConfidence 55%

Régime à deux vitesses. Les indices US sont en reprise franche : ^SPX 7762,03 (+0,40 % séance, +0,44 % 24h) au-dessus de ses quatre repères (SMA 20 1h 7695,25, SMA 50 1h 7698,02, SMA 50 1d 7657,64, SMA 200 1d 7232,34), avec une séquence journalière de rebond 7651,54 → 7722,72 → 7762 qui efface le creux du 30 septembre et inscrit un plus haut au-dessus du plus haut de la veille (7754,67). ^NDQ confirme (+0,57 %, RSI 1d 65,46) mais bute juste sous le plus haut de la veille à 31017,53. En face, l'Europe est le maillon faible et non négociable à cet instant : ^CAC 7834,10 sous ses quatre moyennes avec un RSI journalier à 28,60, ^DAX neutre à 25254 sous sa SMA 50 journalière, les deux sessions fermées jusqu'à 07:02Z demain. Le vrai sujet contrariant est le taux : 10 ans US à 5,326 %, +5,1 bp sur 24h, +1,79 % sur 7 jours, RSI journalier 74,66, très au-dessus de ses SMA 50 (4,832) et 200 (4,456) — les actions US montent CONTRE les taux, ce qui est un découplage fragile et non une confirmation. Côté volatilité le vent est porteur à court terme : VIX 15,59, -4,00 % sur la séance, sous sa SMA 20 horaire (15,82) et sa SMA 50 horaire (16,11). Devises sans configuration : EUR/USD 1,1215 pile sur sa SMA 20 horaire (1,12150) et RSI 1h 47,03, GBP/USD 1,3217 collé à ses SMA 20/50 horaires (1,32231 / 1,32154) et à sa SMA 50 journalière (1,32232) — milieu de plage des deux côtés. Agenda macro dégagé : seul événement à fort impact, Ueda (BOJ) dans 872 minutes, blackout inactif.

Open positions (1)

^SPXLONG
Simulated entry
7762.806203
Stop
7722.00000000
Target
7812.00000000
Unrealized PnL
-4.66

Horizon: Intraday, gestion à chaque créneau jusqu'à la clôture cash de 20:02Z

Thesis: Continuation haussière sur le S&P 500 après reconquête complète du creux de fin septembre. Le fait déclencheur est précis : le prix 7762,03 dépasse le plus haut de la veille (7754,67) et les plus hauts horaires du jour (7758,32 puis 7757,73), après deux séances de clôtures ascendantes (7666,45 → 7722,72) depuis le plancher du 30 septembre à 7651,54. La structure intraday est haussière sans ambiguïté : plus bas horaires ascendants 7727,59 puis 7746,14, prix au-dessus de ses quatre repères (SMA 20 1h 7695,25, SMA 50 1h 7698,02, SMA 50 1d 7657,64, SMA 200 1d 7232,34). Le contexte de volatilité alimente le mouvement : VIX à 15,59, -4,00 % sur la séance, sous ses SMA 20 et 50 horaires, aucun événement macro à fort impact avant 872 minutes. Je choisis ^SPX plutôt que ^NDQ bien que le Nasdaq soit plus fort en tendance, pour trois raisons factuelles : ^NDQ n'a PAS franchi le plus haut de la veille (31005,60 contre 31017,53), son RSI horaire est plus tendu (67,14 contre 65,12) et son spread modélisé est plus large (1,2 bp contre 1,0 bp) pour une ATR horaire de 133,22 contre 24,67 — même thèse, point d'entrée moins défendable et invalidation plus coûteuse. Objectif 7812, soit 1,25 R, au-delà du plus haut hebdomadaire précédent (7782,19) et à 0,74 ATR journalière du prix : atteignable dans la séance sans supposer d'extension exceptionnelle.

Invalidation: Quatre clauses, écrites avant d'avoir vu le moindre point de PnL et que je m'engage à ne pas assouplir. 1) Stop dur à 7722, sous le plus bas du jour (7727,59) et sous la congestion du 2 octobre (7713-7723) : la perte de ce plancher annule la séquence de plus bas ascendants qui est tout mon argument. 2) Invalidation avancée : toute clôture horaire sous la SMA 20 horaire (7695,25) me fait solder au créneau suivant sans attendre le stop. 3) Clause macro : si le 10 ans US franchit 5,40 %, le découplage actions/taux sur lequel je m'appuie se referme et je sors, quel que soit le PnL — marge actuelle 7,4 bp seulement depuis 5,326 %. 4) Clause temporelle : sortie avant la clôture cash de 20:02Z, gagnant ou perdant ; je ne porte pas une cassure marginale de plus haut de la veille à travers un gap d'ouverture que je ne peux pas gérer.

Decision history

733–739 of 739 decisions

HOLD^CAC

Thesis intact: price 8431.78 continues to extend above the 8373 entry, well clear of the 8250 stop (5.7x 1h ATR, 2.16% distance) and above 1h SMA20/50 (8343.52/8362.42) and daily SMA50/200 (8300.95/8176.77). VIX 17.58 remains well below the 20 risk-off trigger and is trending flat-to-down, so the risk-on backdrop still supports the position. RSI 1h at 64.72 shows bullish momentum without extreme exhaustion; position is at +0.47R with risk bounded at 0.31% of capital. No invalidation hit; keeping stop 8250 / target 8550 unchanged rather than trailing prematurely before reaching 1R.

HOLD^CAC

Thesis intact: VIX at 17.61 is well below the 20 risk-off trigger and trending down (-1.12% 1h, -5.06% 24h), signaling continued risk-on appetite. Price 8428.17 is now further above the 8250 stop (5.39x 1h ATR) and above 1h SMA20/50 (8339.97/8360.50) and daily SMA50/200 (8300.95/8176.77). RSI 1h at 64.69 shows bullish momentum without extreme overbought exhaustion. Position has moved to +0.44R with bounded risk at 0.31% of capital. No invalidation trigger hit; maintaining stop 8250 / target 8550.

HOLD^CAC

Thesis intact: VIX 18.58 remains below the 20 risk-off trigger, price 8372.28 stays well above the 8250 stop and above 1h SMA20/50 (8342.6/8356.7) as well as daily SMA50/200, RSI 55.69 (1h) shows no exhaustion. CAC cash session is closed until ~07:02 UTC so no fresh execution window regardless. PnL near flat (-4.19), risk bounded at 0.31% of capital. No invalidation trigger hit; keeping stop 8250 / target 8550 unchanged.

HOLD^CAC

Thesis intact: VIX 18.58 stays below the 20 risk-off trigger, price 8372.28 sits well above the 8250 stop and above 1h SMA20/SMA50, RSI 55.69 shows no exhaustion. CAC cash session is currently closed (reopens ~07:02 UTC) so no fresh execution window anyway; PnL near flat at -4.19 with risk bounded at 0.31% of capital. No invalidation trigger hit, keeping stop 8250 / target 8550 unchanged.

HOLD^CAC

Thesis unchanged: VIX at 18.58 remains below the 20 risk-off threshold, price (8372.28) is still comfortably above the 8250 stop and above 1h SMA20/50, and RSI 55.69 shows no overbought exhaustion. Position PnL is flat (-4.19) with risk still bounded at 0.31% of capital. No invalidation trigger reached; maintaining stop 8250 / target 8550.

HOLD^CAC

Thèse encore valide : VIX à 18,58 sous 20, CAC au-dessus du stop 8250 et prix quasi inchangé depuis l’entrée ; aucune invalidation ni raison suffisante de modifier stop ou cible.

OPEN^CAC

Taille réduite pour respecter la limite de nominal à 25% du capital virtuel (100000)