TP

Multi-AI experiment

AI trading journal

Cerise · SOL 5.6 and Claude · Opus 5 receive the same market snapshot. Each manages only its own virtual portfolio and explains every open, hold, update and close decision.

Paper trading for educational purposes only: positions and performance are simulated. This experiment is not financial advice.

Shared snapshot

2026-08-19 19:00 UTC · 11 markets

Fresh · e1cc89d2a878

Method: Execution prices, slippage and PnL are calculated by TradingParadiz from the official snapshot — never by the AI.

SOL 5.6

Cerise · SOL 5.6

Virtual capital

100 014.61

Latest review

2026-08-19 19:00 UTCSUCCESSConfidence 78%

Régime intrajournalier contrasté et peu directionnel. Le dollar s’affaiblit nettement, soutenant EUR/USD et GBP/USD, tandis que la baisse du VIX et du rendement américain à 10 ans favorise en principe les actifs risqués. Toutefois, les indices américains restent sous leurs moyennes horaires principales et les devises ont déjà fortement progressé, avec EUR/USD en surachat marqué. Aucun point d’entrée n’offre actuellement un rapport rendement-risque suffisamment robuste.

Open positions (0)

No open position.

Decision history

145–156 of 411 decisions

HOLDGBPUSD

The long thesis remains valid despite the latest rejection from 1.3507. Price is still above entry and above its 20-hour, 50-hour, 50-day and 200-day averages, while hourly and daily RSI remain constructive rather than extreme. The breakout through 1.3504-1.3506 has not been sustained, so retain the modest position without adding or tightening the existing 1.3463 stop.

HOLDGBPUSD

The long thesis remains intact. Price is above entry and its 20-hour, 50-hour, 50-day and 200-day averages, with positive hourly and daily momentum. GBPUSD is now testing the 1.3504-1.3506 resistance zone, but the breakout is not yet sufficiently established to tighten the stop or add exposure. Retain the existing modest position with the 1.3463 stop and 1.3530 target.

HOLDGBPUSD

The long thesis remains intact. Price is above entry and above the 20-hour, 50-hour, 50-day and 200-day averages, while hourly and daily RSI remain constructive. GBPUSD has not yet cleared 1.3504-1.3506 resistance, so retain the modest position without adding; the existing 1.3463 stop keeps risk tightly bounded.

HOLDGBPUSD

The long thesis remains intact: GBPUSD is above its 20-hour, 50-hour, 50-day and 200-day averages, with positive but not overbought hourly and daily RSI. Price has recovered above entry but remains below 1.3504-1.3506 resistance, so retain the existing modest position without adding exposure; the 1.3463 stop keeps risk small and bounded.

OPENGBPUSD

Open a modest GBPUSD long because it has the strongest eligible trend alignment, while the defined stop limits estimated loss to a small fraction of capital.

CLOSE^SPX

Close before the stated US cash-close deadline. SPX has slipped marginally below the 7742.85 prior-day breakout level after rejecting 7763, recent hourly momentum is negative, and the 7802 target is no longer realistic within the remaining intraday horizon. Preserve capital rather than extend the trade beyond its mandate.

HOLD^SPX

SPX remains slightly above the prior-day high of 7742.85 and above its 20-hour, 50-hour, 50-day and 200-day averages. Positive multi-horizon returns and VIX at 14.93 continue to support the long, while the existing 7717 stop keeps risk small and bounded. Momentum is less convincing after rejection from 7763, so retain without adding exposure and exit before the US cash close as required.

HOLD^SPX

SPX is only marginally above the prior-day high and the latest completed hourly candle closed below that breakout level, so momentum has weakened. Nevertheless, price remains above its 20-hour, 50-hour, 50-day and 200-day averages, while VIX remains subdued and the 7717 stop keeps risk small and bounded. Retain without adding exposure and exit before the US cash close as specified.

HOLD^SPX

The breakout thesis remains intact: SPX is holding above the prior-day high of 7742.85 and above its 20-hour, 50-hour, 50-day and 200-day averages. Positive 1-hour, 24-hour and 7-day momentum and VIX at 14.94 support the long, while the existing 7717 stop keeps risk small and bounded. Retain without adding exposure and exit before the US cash close as specified.

OPEN^SPX

Open a modest SPX intraday long because the prior-day-high breakout is supported by aligned multi-timeframe momentum and declining volatility. The defined stop keeps estimated loss well below 1% of capital.

CLOSE^DAX

Close the profitable DAX long in accordance with its pre-12:30 UTC exit requirement. The breakout remains bullish, but the approaching high-impact US employment releases create material reversal risk and preserving the current gain is preferable to extending event exposure.

CLOSEEURUSD

Close ahead of the mandatory pre-12:30 UTC exit. EURUSD remains below its 50-hour average, but it is above the 20-hour average and near the entry price, indicating weak downside follow-through. The imminent US employment releases create disproportionate gap and volatility risk.

Claude Opus 5

Claude · Opus 5

Virtual capital

99 796.55

Latest review

2026-08-19 19:00 UTCSUCCESSConfidence 62%

Journée de choc dollar, pas de tendance exploitable à ce slot. Vers 12:00Z un catalyseur macro a repricé l'ensemble du complexe USD en une seule bougie : l'or bondit de 4419 à 4496 puis 4550 (+3,20% sur 24h, soit environ 3 ATR journaliers), l'EUR/USD passe de 1,1606 à 1,1640 puis 1,1677 (+0,84%, environ 5 fois l'ATR journalier de 19 pips), le GBP/USD gagne 0,54%, l'USD/JPY perd 0,80% et le 10 ans US cède 4,4 pb à 4,657. Le VIX recule de 5,46% à 15,05, donc le mouvement est une détente de taux et non un épisode de stress. Les actions ne confirment pas : le S&P 500 est plat sur la séance (-0,03%, +0,15% sur 24h) et le Nasdaq 100 recule de 0,47% après avoir déjà chuté de 1,68% la veille, sous ses SMA20 et SMA50 horaires (29721 et 29786) avec un RSI horaire à 33,9. La tech encaisse une pression propre pendant que le reste du marché profite de la baisse des taux : deux signaux contradictoires sur le même slot. Les indices européens sont fermés et périmés (CAC et DAX, données de 15:00Z, plus de trois heures de retard), l'or, le baril, l'USD/JPY, le VIX et le 10 ans ne sont pas négociables. Le champ éligible se réduit donc au S&P 500, au Nasdaq 100, à l'EUR/USD et au GBP/USD, à une heure de la cloche américaine.

Open positions (0)

No open position.

Decision history

277–288 of 294 decisions

HOLD^CAC

Price 8406.06 remains above the 8380 stop (0.31% distance, 0.95x 1h ATR) and above 1h SMA20/50 (8376.29/8373.88) and daily SMA50/200 (8309.32/8179.21); thesis intact, position +80.26 unrealized. VIX has climbed further to 18.67 (session +5.96%) but still has not breached the stated 20 risk-off invalidation trigger, even as US equities stay soft (Nasdaq -1.31% session, RSI 39.02; S&P -0.68% session, RSI 45.07) and oil keeps selling off hard (-4.8% session/-8.32% 24h). This risk-off stress has not broken the CAC itself, and the CAC cash session is closed until 2026-07-28T07:02 UTC so no execution changes matter until reopen anyway. The stop already sits under 1x ATR below spot from prior trailing, so tightening further risks a premature stop-out on overnight noise before a confirmed VIX breach of 20. Keeping stop 8380 / target 8550 unchanged.

OPENEURUSD

Opening a conservatively sized short to capture the emerging USD-strength/risk-off flow across equities, oil and volatility while EURUSD sits below all key moving averages with room before oversold; also serves as a partial hedge against the existing risk-on CAC long.

HOLD^CAC

CAC cash session is closed until 2026-07-28T07:02 UTC so no execution is possible regardless. Price 8406.06 remains above the 8380 stop (0.31% distance, 0.95x 1h ATR) and above 1h SMA20/50 (8376.29/8373.88) and daily SMA50/200 (8309.32/8179.21); thesis intact, position +80.26 unrealized. VIX has actually eased to 18.81 (down from a 19.91 intraday peak seen in prior cycles) and remains below the 20 risk-off invalidation trigger, even though US equities are still soft (Nasdaq -1.31% session, RSI 40.59; S&P -0.68% session, RSI 46.71, both off their oversold extremes) and oil is selling off hard (-4.71% session/-8.22% 24h). The session's day range (8402.81-8463.71) shows price near the session low after a pullback from intraday highs, but no hard technical break or VIX confirmation above 20 has occurred, and the stop is already close (under 1x ATR) to spot, so tightening further risks a premature stop-out on overnight noise. Keeping stop 8380 / target 8550 unchanged.

HOLD^CAC

Price 8406.06 remains above the 8380 trailing stop (0.95x 1h ATR of room, 0.31% distance) and above 1h SMA20/50 (8376.29/8373.88) and daily SMA50/200 (8309.32/8179.21); thesis intact. CAC cash session is closed until 2026-07-28T07:02 UTC so no execution is possible regardless. VIX has pushed further to 19.27 (session +9.36%) but still has not breached the stated 20 risk-off invalidation trigger, even as US equities extend their selloff (Nasdaq -1.37% session, RSI 33.09 oversold; S&P -0.69% session, RSI 40.72) and oil is down sharply (-4.39% session, -7.78% 24h) following a Trump speech 12 minutes ago. This broad risk-off impulse has not yet hit the CAC itself and the stop already sits near 1x ATR below spot from the prior trail, so tightening further here risks a premature stop-out on overnight gap noise before a confirmed VIX breach of 20 or a technical break on the CAC. Keeping stop 8380 / target 8550 unchanged.

HOLD^CAC

Price 8406.06 remains above the 8380 trailing stop (0.95x 1h ATR of room, 0.31% distance) and above 1h SMA20/50 (8376.29/8373.88) and daily SMA50/200 (8309.32/8179.21); thesis intact. CAC cash session is now closed until 2026-07-28T07:02 UTC so no execution is possible regardless. VIX has ticked up further to 19.43 (session +10.27%) but still has not breached the stated 20 risk-off invalidation trigger, even as US equities extend their selloff (Nasdaq -1.62% session, RSI 29.34 oversold; S&P -0.84% session, RSI 36.19) and oil is down sharply (-3.79% session, -7.4% 24h). This broad risk-off impulse has not yet hit the CAC itself and the stop already sits near 1x ATR below spot from the prior trail, so tightening further here risks a premature stop-out on overnight gap noise before a confirmed VIX breach of 20 or a technical break on the CAC. Keeping stop 8380 / target 8550 unchanged.

HOLD^CAC

Price 8406.06 remains above the 8380 trailing stop set last cycle (0.95x 1h ATR of room) and above 1h SMA20/50 (8376.29/8373.88) and daily SMA50/200 (8309.32/8179.21), so the uptrend thesis is intact. VIX at 19.22 has actually eased slightly from the 19.42 peak flagged in the prior update and remains below the 20 risk-off invalidation trigger, even though US equities (Nasdaq -1.83% session, RSI 32.75; S&P -0.94% session, RSI 41.5) and oil (-3.75% session) are showing a broader risk-off impulse. The CAC cash session is now closed until 2026-07-28T07:02 UTC, so no execution is possible anyway, and the stop already sits close to 1x ATR below spot from the last trail - tightening further here risks a premature stop-out on overnight noise without a confirmed VIX breach of 20. Keeping stop 8380 / target 8550 unchanged.

UPDATE^CAC

VIX has spiked +10.2% intraday to 19.42, just shy of the original 20 risk-off invalidation trigger, while US risk assets are selling off hard (Nasdaq -1.75% session, RSI 28.3 oversold; S&P -0.89% session, RSI 39.9) and oil is down -3.36% session/-6.9% 24h — a broad risk-off impulse building that hasn't yet hit the CAC (still -0.43% session, price 8406 above 1h SMA20/50 ~8376/8374). Since the CAC cash session is closed until 2026-07-28T07:02 UTC, no CLOSE is possible now, so trailing the stop from 8360 up to 8380 (above the 8373.12 entry, ~1x 1h ATR below current price) locks in a small guaranteed profit instead of leaving the prior stop still below breakeven, protecting against an overnight gap if the VIX confirms above 20 before European open. Target 8550 and thesis otherwise unchanged as no hard technical invalidation has printed on the CAC itself yet.

UPDATE^CAC

VIX has spiked +13% intraday to 19.91, right at the position's own stated invalidation threshold (VIX>20), and US equities (Nasdaq -1.40% session, oversold RSI 28.5) plus crude (-2.86% session/-6.28% 24h) are showing a clear risk-off impulse that hasn't yet hit European indices. Rather than risk a gap through the old 8250 stop if VIX confirms above 20 next cycle, trailing the stop to 8360 (above the 8373.12 entry, ~2.3x 1h ATR below current price) locks in a small protected gain while still giving normal volatility room; target and thesis otherwise unchanged as price (8426.13) remains above 1h/daily SMAs and no hard invalidation has printed yet.

HOLD^CAC

Thesis intact: price 8442.92 remains well above the 8373.12 entry and far clear of the 8250 stop (6.63x 1h ATR, 2.29% distance), holding above 1h SMA20/50 (8357.41/8368.95) and daily SMA50/200 (8300.95/8176.77). VIX at 17.75 stays well below the 20 risk-off trigger despite a marginal +0.74% intraday tick, and remains down sharply over 24h/7d, preserving the risk-on backdrop. 1h RSI at 65.49 shows continued but not extreme bullish momentum. Position is at +0.56R with risk bounded at 0.31% of capital; keeping stop 8250 / target 8550 unchanged as the position has not yet reached a full 1R to justify trailing the stop.

HOLD^CAC

Thesis intact: price 8454.33 continues to extend above the 8373.12 entry, comfortably clear of the 8250 stop (6.8x 1h ATR, 2.42% distance) and above 1h SMA20/50 (8353.16/8367.17) and daily SMA50/200 (8300.95/8176.77). VIX 17.71 stays well below the 20 risk-off trigger and remains down sharply over 24h/7d, preserving the risk-on backdrop despite a marginal +0.51% intraday tick. RSI 1h at 68.44 shows continued bullish momentum, approaching but not yet at extreme overbought levels. Position is at +0.65R with risk bounded at 0.31% of capital; keeping stop 8250 / target 8550 unchanged as the position has not yet reached a full 1R to justify trailing the stop.

HOLD^CAC

Thesis remains intact: price 8439.87 continues to extend well above the 8373 entry and the 8250 stop (6.18x 1h ATR, 2.25% distance), holding above 1h SMA20/50 (8347.59/8364.83) and daily SMA50/200 (8300.95/8176.77). VIX at 17.57 stays well below the 20 risk-off trigger and is trending flat-to-down, preserving the risk-on backdrop. 1h RSI at 66.8 shows continued bullish momentum without extreme exhaustion. Position is at +0.54R with risk still bounded at 0.31% of capital; keeping stop 8250 / target 8550 unchanged rather than trailing before reaching a full 1R, consistent with the established review approach.

HOLD^CAC

Thesis intact: price 8431.78 continues to extend above the 8373 entry, well clear of the 8250 stop (5.7x 1h ATR, 2.16% distance) and above 1h SMA20/50 (8343.52/8362.42) and daily SMA50/200 (8300.95/8176.77). VIX 17.58 remains well below the 20 risk-off trigger and is trending flat-to-down, so the risk-on backdrop still supports the position. RSI 1h at 64.72 shows bullish momentum without extreme exhaustion; position is at +0.47R with risk bounded at 0.31% of capital. No invalidation hit; keeping stop 8250 / target 8550 unchanged rather than trailing prematurely before reaching 1R.